The Menu
Scratch American food,
on the water.
Everything's made to order from house recipes — burgers, steaks, pizzas, tacos and shareable apps, served over Buttons Bay.
Appetizers
Made fresh to order from house recipes
Hummus $16
Pureed chickpea, red pepper coulis, olive tapenade, cucumber, carrot, celery & pita.
Wisconsin Cheese Curds $16
House-cut cheddar, Spotted Cow beer-battered, fried & dusted in parmesan & parsley. Served with ranch & marinara.
Fried Pickles $15
Waffle-cut chips floured, fried & dusted in dill. Served with ranch & chipotle mayo.
Big Bavarian $22
This giant pretzel is for the table to share. Salted & baked, served with nacho cheese & honey mustard.
Little Bavarian. $15
Share if you want. Served with nacho cheese & honey mustard.
Smoked Wings $18
6 jumbo wings, smoked & fried. Your choice of BBQ, lemon-pepper-dry, hot or mild buffalo. Served with ranch or bleu cheese.
Meatball $21
3 beef & sausage meatballs, marinara, parmesan, arugula.
Slider Trio $18 / $21
3 mini brioche buns. Your choice of BBQ pulled pork ($18) or tenderloin steak tips with garlic mayo ($21).
Cheese Quesadilla $15
Flour tortilla, shredded cheese, served with salsa & sour cream. Add shredded chicken $6, pulled pork $6, steak $8.
Fried Shrooms $15
Sliced portabella mushrooms, beer-battered, deep-fried, dusted in parmesan & parsley. Served with ranch & chipotle mayo.
Tacos
Served with lime & jalapeño. Choose corn or flour tortilla. Order 3 tacos and rice & beans are included.
Steak *$10
Piedmontese grassfed hanger steak, pico de gallo, salsa verde.
Shrimp$10
Colossal Atlantic shrimp, beer battered & fried, cabbage slaw, pickled red onion, chipotle mayo.
Chicken$8
Seasoned & shredded chicken, cilantro, onion, sour cream.
Gringo$8
Seasoned ground beef, lettuce, tomato, cheddar, sour cream.
Burgers
Fresh 1/2lb Angus from Northwest Meat Co, homestyle bun, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle & fries. Substitute Angus for grassfed patty, chicken breast, portabella cap, or veggie patty.
Boat House Burger *$20
American cheese, bacon.
Juicy Lucy *$22
Smoked gouda, pineapple wheel, bacon, BBQ.
Jalapeno *$20
Pepper jack, fried jalapeno, chipotle mayo.
G-Series *$24
Piedmontese grassfed patty, gouda, garlic, greens.
MOAB *$28
Dual beef patties, quad cheese, fried egg, fresh jalapeno.
Oinkn' Onion *$26
American cheese, baconnaise, sautéed onions.
Steaks, Chops & Fish
Served with garlic mashed potatoes & seasonal vegetables. Your choice of soup or salad. Dinner sides: mashed potatoes $4 · bleu cheese crumbles $8 · sautéed mushrooms $4 · sautéed vegetables $8.
Surf & Turf *$74
8oz USDA Prime filet grilled to temp & 5 colossal Atlantic shrimp.
Tenderloin Tip *$40
8oz tenderloin tip grilled to temp, sautéed mushrooms & onions.
Salmon$40
6oz wild Atlantic filet, teriyaki glaze & sesame seeds. Served with rice — no potato.
Filet Mignon *$60
8oz USDA Prime filet grilled to temp.
Pork Chop$34
12oz bone-in french cut chop, honey mustard glaze.
NY-Strip *$52
14oz Prime NY-Strip grilled to temp.
Pastas
Served with soup or salad & garlic bread.
Button's Bay$35
Chicken, sun dried tomato, garlic cream sauce, penne.
Portside$32
Portobello mushroom, garlic cream sauce, gnocchi.
Chicken Parm$34
Breaded chicken, mozzarella, marinara, spaghetti.
Vodka$34
Chicken, vodka cream sauce, cheese tortellini.
Piccata$38
Chicken breast, lemon caper sauce, capellini.
LG Pasta$34
3 homemade beef & pork meatballs, marinara, spaghetti.
Como Pasta$34
Artichoke, mushroom, spinach, cherry tomato, white wine cream sauce, pappardelle.
Shrimp Scampi$35
5 sautéed shrimp, garlic white wine butter sauce, capellini.
Salads
Add protein: chicken breast 6oz $10 · shrimp (5) $14 · salmon filet 6oz $15 · tenderloin tips 8oz $20. Dressings: ranch, bleu cheese, caesar, french, honey mustard, balsamic, greek, lemon-oregano, 1000 island.
Caprese$18
Fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, oil & balsamic reduction.
House$18
Spring mix, cucumber, tomato, carrot, onion, crouton. Choose a dressing.
Bay Breeze$18
Spinach, feta, red onion, seasonal fruit, walnut, balsamic vinaigrette.
Mediterranean$22
Arugula, chickpea, cucumber, feta, red onion, red pepper, greek vinaigrette.
Pizzas
14" thin crust or 10" gluten free.
Aloha$26
Red sauce, mozz, ham, pineapple.
Basic$30
Pesto sauce, feta, garlic, green pepper, spinach.
BBQ Chicken$26
BBQ sauce, mozz, chicken, red onion.
Boomer$26
White sauce, mozz, portabella, garlic, onion.
Geneva$28
Red sauce, mozz, pepperoni, sausage, bacon.
Margherita$30
Red sauce, fresh mozz, basil, garlic, tomato.
The JG$30
Red sauce, mozz, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, garlic.
The Caddy$30
Red sauce, mozz, pepperoni, sausage, arugula, jalapeño, hot honey.
Build Your Own$22
Toppings $2 each. Sauce: red, BBQ, oil, pesto. Cheese: mozzarella, feta, fresh buffalo mozzarella +$3. Veg: basil, olives, garlic, giardiniera, peppers, jalapeño, mushroom, portabella, onion, pineapple, tomato. Meat: bacon, chicken, ham, pepperoni, sausage, pulled pork, taco beef.
Sandwiches
Served with fries.
Cubano$24
Slow roasted pork, ham, swiss, dijonaise, pickles, hoagie.
Meatball$24
3 beef & sausage meatballs, marinara, mozzarella, arugula, hoagie.
Nashville Chicken$24
Crispy fried chicken breast, spicy sauce, chipotle mayo, pickles, burger bun.
Caprese Chicken$24
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, balsamic reduction, hoagie.
Grilled Chicken$18
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, burger bun.
Pulled Pork$22
Slow roasted BBQ pork butt, coleslaw, burger bun.
Steak Tips$28
8oz tenderloin tips, sautéed mushroom & onion, garlic mayo, hoagie.
BLT$18
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, panini.
Shipwreck$22
BBQ pork, pepperjack, sautéed onion, panini.
Kids Menu
For kids under 12 only. Served with fries.
Chicken Tenders$12
Cheeseburger$12
Grilled Cheese$12
Kraft® Mac & Cheese$10
PB n' J$10
Kids Taco$8
Ground beef & shredded cheese. No fries.
Sides
Chips $10 Fries $8
Coleslaw $6 Sweet Potato Fries $10
Side Salad $12 Extra Sauces $1–2
Homemade SoupCup $8 / Bowl $10
Dessert
All desserts made in house.
Carrot Cake $10 Chocolate Torte $10
Cheesecake $10 Key Lime Pie $10
Items marked with an asterisk (*) are cooked to your temperature. Menu and prices are set in-house and can change with the season — please confirm current offerings on your visit or by phone.
From The Bar
Cold beer, hand-crafted cocktails, and a wine list built for the deck — plus a rotating tap and seasonal cocktail menu, so ask your server what's pouring today.
Beers —Local and regional favorites, rotating with the season — New Glarus Spotted Cow Always on Tap
-
Budweiser 5.0%
Busch Light 4.1%
Coors Light 4.2%
Michelob Ultra 4.2%
Miller Lite 4.2%
Miller 64 3.0%
PBR Tallboy 4.7% n
-
Corona 4.5%
Corona Light 3.9%
Guinness 4.2%
Hacker Pschorr 5.0%
Heineken 5.4%
Modelo 4.4%
Peroni 5.1%
Stella Artois 5.0%
-
Daisy Cutter 5.2% - Half Acre
Dirty Bastard 8.2% - Founders
Lil Sumpin’ 7.5% - Lagunitas
Wisconsinitis 5.0% - 3 Sheeps
-
Angry Orchard Crisp Apple 5.0%
Twisted Tea GF 5.0%
Sun Cruiser Tea GF 4.5%
Carbliss 5.0%
Hard Lemonade 5.2%
High Noon: Black Cherry 4.5%
Grapefruit, Pineapple, Peach
-
90 Min 9.2% - Dogfish Head
Lagunitas 6.2% - Lagunitas
Two Hearted 7.0% - Bell’s
-
Heineken 00 0.0%
-
Badger Club 5.5% - Wisconsin
Riverwest Stein 5.6% - Lakefront
-
New Grist GF 5.1%- Lakefront
-
Rotating Porter ?%
-
Summer Shandy 4.2% - Leinenkugel’s
Wines — By the Glass or Bottle
A curated list built for the deck, from crisp whites to bold reds.
-
House: Twenty Acres
Quilt: Napa Valley, CA
Federalist: CA - Btl Only
Justin: Paso Robles, CA - Btl Only
-
House: Rotating
Quilt: Napa Valley, CA
-
Brassfield Eruption, CA
Federalist, CA - Btl Only
Decoy: Sonoma, CA - Btl Only
Prisoner: Napa, CA - Btl Only
-
House: Sterling
Fruili: Terlato Vineyards, ITA
-
House: The Seeker: Germany
Lovelock: Marlborough, NZ
-
House: Rotating
Jackson Estate: Santa Maria, CA
Federalist: Sonoma, CA - Btl only
-
The Seeker: Germany
-
Hampton Water: Languedoc, FRA
-
Zonin Prosecco
Brut Champagne